Here’s an article from a great fielding-analysis blog about the value of OF throwing arms. Here are the runs prevented compared to average on a per-season basis over the years 2002-2005.
Ten Best Outfielder Arms
Name Runs Saved
1 . Edmonds Jim 8.718
2 . Jones Jacque 8.659
3 . Taveras Willy 8.074
4 . Johnson Kelly 7.772
5 . Sullivan Cory 7.372
6 . Chavez Endy 6.524
7 . Guerrero Vladimir 6.197
8 . Hidalgo Richard 6.181
9 . Hunter Torii 5.974
10 . Walker Larry 5.852
Ten Worst Outfielder Arms
Name Runs Cost
1 . Brown Emil -16.783
2 . Pierre Juan -10.769
3 . Lawton Matt -9.428
4 . Sanchez Alex -7.793
5 . Holliday Matthew -7.341
6 . Crawford Carl -7.111
7 . DeJesus David -6.996
8 . Williams Bernie -6.785
9 . White Rondell -6.559
10 . Magee Wendell -5.973
Emil Brown’s out of control. But even ignoring him, the difference between a great throwing arm and a bad one is 20 runs per season — that’s two wins and the difference between David Wright and Derek Jeter at the plate. All from an ARM.
The researchers also make available a spreadsheet with data for all players from 2002-2005. Here are some interesting tidbits:
- Johnny Damon’s right at league-average, surprisingly
- The best 2002 arm belonged to Chipper Jones, saving 18 runs in 534 opportunities. Vlad was second at 17 runs.
- The best two single seasons by far were Aaron Rowand in 2005 (26 runs!) and Ichiro in 2004 (23 runs!)
- On the bottom of the scale a few players posted seasons in the -18 runs range: Juan Pierre, Alex Sanchez, Reed Johnson, Damon Hollins, and Emil Brown.
- Andruw Jones ranks as the 11th best arm overall in the period.
- Jermaine Dye, who I’ve always heard has a great arm, comes in at -4 runs per season, barely better than Shannon Stewart.
Popularity: 2% [?]
Share This
Sky is a baseball fan and racket sport afficianado living in upstate NY. His favorite color is orange and is just about ready to give up on his life-long dream to become the next Magnus ver Magnuson (World's Strongest Man). His favorite baseball teams are the Yankees and Red Sox, proving that there's hope in the Middle East.
August 31st, 2007 at 3:08 pm
There is no way you’re getting me to believe Johnny Damon, who has basically lost his job in CF to Melky Cabrera because of his defense, has a league average arm.